In the ACT, the Supreme Court may redirect charitable trust property under a cy-près scheme where the original charitable purpose cannot be fulfilled due to impossibility, impracticality or unlawfulness.
Cy-Pres Scheme
Cy-près means “as near as possible” and derives from Old French. A cy-près scheme requires evidence of a general charitable intention, not one limited to a specific entity or method. The Supreme Court exercises inherent equitable jurisdiction to alter charitable trusts in the ACT, supplemented by the Trustee Act 1925 and the Charitable Collections Act 2003. An application is made to the Supreme Court, typically by the trustee of the charitable trust or by another interested party such as the executor of a Will or an affected beneficiary. The applicant in a cy-près application prepares and files supporting documents, including;
- the original trust deed or will,
- evidence showing that the original charitable purpose cannot be fulfilled, and
- a proposal for a new charitable purpose closely aligned with the donor’s intentions.
The application;
- provides all relevant background information,
- clarifies the reasons for the failure of the original purpose,
- demonstrates a general charitable intention, and
- explainins why the proposed new purpose is appropriate.
Notice may need to be given to interested parties or those who might have benefited under the original terms, and the Court may require service of the application or publication of notice. The Court then considers whether to approve the proposed cy-près scheme, ensuring the new arrangement is as close as possible to the donor’s intentions and the public benefit is preserved. An applicant ensures documentation is complete, addresses the relevant circumstances, and meets the legal requirements for cy-près relief. If a charitable trust or gift fails, trustees or interested parties may apply to the Supreme Court for approval to redirect assets to a similar charitable purpose.
The Court determines whether a general charitable intention existed, assesses the suitability of the proposed alternative, and considers alignment with the original intention. Court approval is required before distribution. This process ensures charitable property is applied as nearly as possible to the intended public benefit.
A change in the recipient’s name or structure does not defeat a charitable gift.
In Estate of Titterton [2026] ACTSC 398 Andrew Brian Titterton (the deceased) directed part of his estate to support a rescue helicopter service. At the time of his death, the fundraising company named in the deceased’s Will had been deregistered, creating uncertainty concerning a gift of approximately $190,000. Requiring the Supreme Court of the ACT to determine whether the gift failed or whether the Will could be construed to give effect to the deceased’s intentions.
The gift and the residuary estate
The deceased died on 19 August 2024, leaving an estate valued at approximately $1.7 million. The deceased was survived by no spouse, children or parents. The Supreme Court registry granted probate to the executors, Jason Deane Parkinson and Jacqueline Ann Cauchi (the first and second applicants) on 27 November 2024 under a Will (the 2014 Will) dated 29 January 2014. The 2014 Will divided the residuary estate among several beneficiaries, including a share to “Snowy Hydro Southcare” at an address in Majura, ACT. Snowy Hydro Southcare was a business name used by Southcare Helicopter Fund Pty Ltd, which acted as trustee of a fundraising trust supporting aeromedical and rescue services. For the purposes of this application, part of the residue of the estate was dealt with in clause 3.3.4, in the following terms:
“As to the one share to SNOWY HYDRO SOUTHCARE of 4 Point Cook Avenue, Majura ACT 2600.“
That portion of the residue is valued at approximately $190,000. The executors are concerned that, if the gift to Snowy Hydro Southcare is interpreted strictly, it will fail, resulting in an intestacy in respect of that portion of the estate. The applicants’ concern stems from Snowy Hydro Southcare not being a legal entity or a registered charity. It was previously a registered business name but is no longer. The fundraising arrangement ended when Toll Helicopters assumed equipment contracts in 2016 or 2017. The trust and its corporate trustee were dissolved and deregistered in December 2017, before the deceased’s death. The applicants sought orders to the following effect, and in the alternative:
- (a) judicial advice as to the proper construction of clause 3.3.4 of the Will; or
- (b) rectification of the Will pursuant to s12A of the Wills Act 1968 (ACT); or
- (c) a Cy-près order to give effect to the testator’s wishes by substituting another charitable beneficiary with similar objects to the named beneficiary.
Equitable Tracing
Equitable tracing in the ACT is grounded primarily in common law and equitable principles established by the High Court of Australia and applied by the Supreme Court of the ACT.
The Jurisdictional Base: Consistent with Australian equity jurisprudence, the ACT Supreme Court does not require an absolute, pre-existing fiduciary relationship before tracing can begin. Instead, it considers whether a sufficient proprietary basis exists or whether unauthorised interference with rights warrants equitable intervention to prevent unjust enrichment or protect property rights.
Application of Mixing Rules: If a trustee or fiduciary in Canberra misappropriates funds and mixes them with personal assets, the ACT Supreme Court applies standard Australian tracing rules:
The Rogue First Rule: Under Re Hallett’s Estate, the wrongdoer is presumed to spend their own money first.
The Cherry-Picking Rule: In Re Oatway [1903] 2 Ch 356, if any part of the mixed fund is used to purchase a profitable asset, the claimant can claim that asset.
The Lowest Intermediate Balance Rule: Claimants cannot trace beyond the lowest balance in the account between the time the funds were mixed and the time of the claim (Caron v Jahani).
Statutory Intersections: Although tracing is a judge-made mechanism, it is often used in the ACT to pursue remedies for breaches of statutory trusts, including those under the Trustee Act 1925 (ACT) and civil construction security-of-payment statutory trusts.
The applicants submitted evidence tracing the fundraising organisation’s relationship with ACT & SE NSW Aero Medical Service Ltd (AMS). AMS, established in 1998, oversees contractual arrangements supporting search-and-rescue medical services in the ACT and south-east NSW.
Under the previous structure, the Southcare trust advanced funds to AMS after operating expenses. The aeromedical service continued after the fundraising arrangement ceased.
In Estate of Titterton, the applicants provided evidence of the deceased’s intentions, including file notes, emails, and recorded conversations during the Will’s preparation that referred to the Southcare helicopter service and related terms, indicating that the deceased intended to support the service associated with the Southcare name.
Partial intestacy and the failed gift
A partial intestacy occurs when a person leaves a valid Will that:
- fails to distribute all their assets, either by failing to allocate some of their property or by failing to include a clause that would allocate that property; or
- names a beneficiary who has died, and the Will does not provide for another beneficiary to receive their share of the inheritance.
In the Estate of Titterton, a partial intestacy can occur for several reasons. Often, it happens because the Will fails to account for certain contingencies or address all the estate’s assets.
The rules governing the distribution of the property of a person who dies partially intestate are similar to those laid down for total intestacy: s 49D of the Administration and Probate Act 1925(ACT).
No spouse, children or parents survived the deceased. If the gift failed, under snthat portion of the estate would pass to the deceased’s sister under intestacy. The evidence indicated this outcome was inconsistent with the deceased’s intentions. The Will provided for her two sons, but not for her sister.
The submissions addressed the broader context of the deceased’s testamentary intentions. The central issue was whether the Will could properly identify AMS as the intended recipient.
When is it appropriate to give judicial advice?
The decision to give judicial advice is discretionary. The court’s overriding consideration is whether giving advice would serve the best interests of the trust or estate: Re Estate of Chow Cho-Poon [2013] NSWSC 844; Re Application of Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd [2003] NSWSC 1185; Estate of Cervo [2024] ACTSC 253.
Section 63 of the Trustee Act 1925 (ACT) provides that Judicial advice is appropriate where it advances the best interests of the estate, particularly by resolving uncertainty regarding administration or distribution and protecting trustees who act on the advice. However the court is not obliged to provide it.
Muller J held that the application fell within the scope, allowing trustees to seek judicial advice on administering trust property or interpreting a trust instrument. Evidence submitted demonstrated the deceased’s intention to benefit the organisation providing aeromedical and rescue services in the ACT. Contemporaneous file notes, correspondence, and client instructions consistently identified the Southcare helicopter service as an intended beneficiary. Additionally, the deceased did not intend his sister to benefit from the estate.
Muller J held that the advice sought would protect the estate’s interests and help make a distribution that beneficiaries might otherwise challenge. His Honour concluded that the reference to “Snowy Hydro Southcare” in the Will should be construed as referring to AMS.
Rectification as an alternative
Section 12A permits rectification where the wording of a Will fails to give effect to the testator’s intentions. If judicial advice had not been appropriate, Muller J indicated that the evidence of the deceased’s intention to support the entity responsible for the aeromedical service was overwhelming, and that it would have rectified the Will under section 12A of the Wills Act 1968 (ACT). Rectification was not required. By resolving the application through interpretation, Muller J did not need to consider the proposed cy-près alternative.
AMS undertook to hold the inheritance in a separate bank account and apply it solely to equipment for the relevant aeromedical service. The funds would not be used for ordinary operating expenses or paid to the ACT or NSW governments. Muller J acknowledged this undertaking and ordered that the application costs be paid from the estate.
Practical implications for charitable gifts
A familiar fundraising name may identify a service to a donor but create uncertainty concerning the legal recipient of a testamentary gift.
Estate of Titterton [2026] ACTSC 398 highlights the importance of accurately identifying the intended organisation and maintaining detailed records of the will-maker’s instructions. Contemporaneous notes and correspondence established the link between the name in the Will and the service the deceased intended to support.
Practitioners can reduce the risk of disputes over charitable gifts by adopting several safeguards:
- Verify and use the current legal name and registered details of each intended beneficiary;
- Where appropriate, include ABNs or charity registration numbers;
- Briefly describe the charity’s purpose to clarify intent;
- Where possible, consult the charity to confirm its legal status and preferred bequest wording;
- Include fallback or substitutional gift clauses if the intended recipient no longer exists or has changed, naming alternative charities with similar purposes or giving the executor or trustee discretion to select a substitute;
- Maintain clear records of the testator’s instructions and preferences to assist the Court if the beneficiary’s identity is later disputed
Estate of Titterton underscores the need to review charitable gifts carefully, as an organisation’s name, structure or fundraising arrangements may change before the gift takes effect. Importantly the matter may influence how courts interpret charitable gifts where the intended recipient has changed or no longer exists.
Will drafting and estate litigation in the ACT may increasingly focus on evidence of the testator’s intentions and contemporaneous records, rather than a strict reading of the names in the Will. Maintaining detailed records and drafting with flexibility remain important to reduce dispute risk and ensure charitable gifts are applied as intended.
Checklist for practitioners
Best practices when drafting charitable gifts and keeping relevant records
- Confirm and use the current legal name and registered details of each intended beneficiary
- Where available, include ABNs or charity registration numbers
- Briefly describe the charity’s purpose to clarify the testator’s intent
- Consult with intended charities where possible to verify legal status and preferred bequest wording
- Include fallback or substitutional clauses to direct gifts if the original recipient no longer exists, such as naming alternative charities with similar purposes or authorising the executor/trustee to select a substitute
- Keep records of all instructions, correspondence, and dialogues documenting the testator’s wishes
- Review charitable gifts regularly to ensure the continued accuracy of beneficiary details
A clear checklist promotes best practice and helps safeguard against disputes or unintended outcomes in administering charitable gifts.
In Estate of Titterton [2026] ACTSC 398 His Honour provided the following advice under s 63 of the Trustee Act 1925 (ACT):
(1) The reference in clause 3.3.4 of the 2014 Will, dated 29 January 2014, to “Snowy Hydro Southcare of 4 Point Cook Avenue Majura ACT 2600” is to be read as referring to ACT & SE NSW Aero Medical Service Ltd (ABN 52 083 187 884) (AMS). The costs of the application are to be paid out of the estate on a solicitor-client basis. Noting that AMS has undertaken to keep any funds received from the deceased’s estate in a separate bank account and to expend those funds only on equipment for the relevant aero-medical service.
