Geoffrey Baxter (the deceased) died without a Will. Under the intestacy rules, his sister, Vicki Glennon (the appellant), was appointed administrator of his estate and, subject to an order for provision under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) (the Act), was entitled to the whole of the estate, including the deceased’s residence at Tyndale (Tyndale). Kylie Robinson (the respondent) following a nine-year intermittent relationship with the deceased were living separately at the deceased’s death. The respondent advanced her claim based on periods of shared accommodation and mutual support.
On 11 December 2025, in Robinson v Glennon [2025] NSWSC 770, Brereton J found that the respondent was partially dependent on the deceased. His Honour weighed the couple’s enduring connection and the respondent’s financial needs against their separation and troubled history. Over nine years, the respondent had been the deceased’s principal romantic and domestic partner. They had considered themselves engaged, and Tyndale was the closest thing the respondent had to a settled home. The respondent repeatedly returned, often at the deceased’s invitation, and contributed through household work, gardening and groceries. The respondent’s lack of assets, reliance on Centrelink, health difficulties and limited accommodation options also supported provision.
Against this were their separation before the deceased’s death, repeated violence and estrangement, and reciprocal apprehended domestic violence orders. Ultimately, Brereton J considered the relationship as a whole. Despite its destructive episodes, the couple maintained an attachment that repeatedly brought them back together. Their final separation did not erase nine years of shared domestic life. Robinson was therefore someone Baxter could reasonably have been expected to provide for in his estate.
The Appeal
The appellant appeals against the orders made by Brereton J on 11 December 2025 under s 59 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), which provided for a distribution from the deceased’s estate in favour of the respondent. His Honour ordered that the whole of the estate, including the deceased’s residence at Tyndale (Tyndale), be transferred to the respondent subject to payment of certain estate debts. As the deceased died intestate, the appellant became entitled to the whole of his estate, subject to an order for provision being made under the Act. The respondent, with whom the deceased had a long-term intermittent intimate relationship, claimed provision from the estate in proceedings brought in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court. Tyndale was the only substantial asset in the deceased’s estate.
Glennon v Robinson [2026] NSWCA 235 is an appeal against the orders made by Brereton J on three bases:
- The eligibility challenge: s 57(1)(e) of the Act (ground 1);
- The challenge to the “factors warranting” the making of the application for an order for provision: s 59(1)(b) of the Act (grounds 2-5); and
- The challenge to the provision order made by the primary judge: s 59(2) of the Act (grounds 6-7).
Leave to appeal is not required as the appeal involves an amount in issue of more than $100,000: s 101(2)(r) of the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW). Tyndale is worth about $330,000. The net value of the estate is $315,366.84, from which the appellant’s costs, capped at $100,000, must also be deducted. The appellant seeks to set aside the order for provision.
The decision confirms that a successful family provision application can displace an entitlement arising under intestacy.
Factual Background
The deceased and the respondent had a relationship marked by repeated separations and reconciliations. The evidence included incidents of domestic violence, police involvement, and reciprocal apprehended domestic violence orders.
The respondent resided at Tyndale for substantial periods. The appellant accepted that the respondent had lived with the deceased for at least two and a half years during the nine-year relationship. The respondent did not contribute to the mortgage or payment of council or water rates. The deceased provided accommodation, while the respondent contributed domestic assistance and groceries on occasion. The relationship involved multiple periods of cohabitation, interrupted by separations and reconciliations. Brereton J found that, despite intermittent separations, the parties maintained contact and shared aspects of daily life. The respondent last left Tyndale in May 2023. The deceased died in August 2023. The respondent became aware of the deceased’s death approximately six weeks later.
Partial dependency: the first threshold
The respondent’s claim was not contingent on establishing de facto status at the date of death. The Succession Act 2006 (NSW) recognises temporary and partial dependency. Partial dependency may arise where a claimant occasionally relies on the deceased for financial assistance or accommodation, without the deceased being the sole source of support. The respondent was not required to establish that the deceased was her sole source of accommodation or sustenance.
The respondent’s extended occupation of Tyndale, together with their financial circumstances, supported the finding that their dependence exceeded the minimal statutory threshold. Establishing eligibility enabled the Court to consider the application but did not confer an automatic entitlement to provision.
Had the relationship ended?
The appellant further submitted that the relationship had ended prior to the deceased’s death. Evidence supporting that submission included the reciprocal domestic violence orders, statements describing the respondent as single or estranged, and the delay before the respondent became aware of the deceased’s death. Brereton J considered these matters in the context of the relationship as a whole. His Honour accepted evidence that the parties continued to meet despite the domestic violence orders. The respondent retained keys to Tyndale. The deceased told the respondent, prior to their last departure, that they could return and that it would remain their home following the deceased’s death. His Honour found it was not possible to determine whether the final separation would have become permanent had the deceased lived longer.
The Court of Appeal found no error demonstrated in that assessment.
Factors Warranting the Application
Eligibility was established under s 57(1)(e), followed by a separate inquiry into whether factors warranted the application. Brereton J noted the difficulty in treating the respondent as a person whom the deceased ought to have considered, given the history of violence and reciprocal protective orders. His Honour balanced these factors against the evidence of dependency. While the relationship included conflict and protective orders, Brereton J accepted that dependency and the overall nature of the relationship could justify provision. The application addressed both positive and negative relationship factors.
The Court assessed whether dependency and need outweighed adverse circumstances in determining provision. The assessment extended to:
- the duration of the relationship,
- substantial periods of shared residence,
- emotional attachment, and
- mutual practical dependence.
The Court of Appeal upheld that assessment. The weight given to the relevant circumstances was primarily a matter for Brereton J. The appellant had not established an error warranting an appellate court’s intervention.
Extent of Provision
The extent of provision reflected the competing circumstances of the parties as assessed by the Court. The estate was modest. The respondent had limited assets, relied on government payments, and had restricted access to support. Their needs related to accommodation, food, and health care. The appellant, while experiencing health concerns, was comparatively secure financially.
The Court of Appeal held that awarding the respondent the whole net estate was within Brereton J’s available range of reasonable outcomes. His Honour dismissed the appellant’s submission that the respondent’s rent-free occupation of Tyndale following the deceased’s death satisfied any provision obligation. Temporary accommodation did not exhaust the claim arising from the respondent’s ongoing needs. Receipt of the net estate did not necessarily enable the respondent to retain the house. The judgment recognised that deductions from the estate would likely require the sale of Tyndale, necessitating alternative accommodation.
Estate planning lesson
Robinson v Glennon [2025] NSWSC 770 does not establish that every former partner or occasional houseguest will succeed in a claim against an estate. The decision demonstrates the importance of distinguishing three questions:
- eligibility,
- whether factors warrant the application, and
- whether adequate provision has been made.
The decision also illustrates that the final separation may not be determinative in complex relationships. Shared accommodation, practical support, and ongoing connections may remain relevant after cohabitation ceases.
For estate practitioners, order of inheritance is the starting point. A successful family provision application may substantially alter the distribution, including the possibility that the entire net estate is awarded to an applicant.
Proactive estate planning reduces the risk of similar disputes. Preparing a valid and current Will that identifies intended beneficiaries and the reasons for decisions is essential. Documenting financial or personal support provided to non-family members or intermittent partners, and maintaining clear records of relationships and dependencies, can help clarify intentions. For clients with complex or non-traditional family arrangements, regularly reviewing and documenting the estate plan may reduce the likelihood of future claims.
